Resources

When Your Insurance Company Betrays You: Understanding Bad Faith and Your Legal Rights When you file an insurance claim, your insurance company has a legal obligation to act fairly, investigate thoroughly, and pay valid claims promptly. But sometimes insurers deliberately delay, deny valid claims, ignore evidence, or use deceptive tactics to avoid paying. This is “insurance bad faith”—and California law provides strong protections, allowing you to sue your own insurance company for damages far beyond the original claim amount. At Sky Law Group in Orange County, we’ve helped clients recover millions in bad faith lawsuits against insurance companies that wrongfully denied their claims. This guide explains what constitutes bad faith, your legal rights, and how to fight back. What Is Insurance Bad Faith Under California Law? Insurance bad faith is defined in California Insurance Code §790.03, which prohibits insurers from committing any “unfair method, act, or practice” in insurance transactions. More specifically, case law (particularly Gruenberg v. Aetna Insurance Co., 1990) defines bad faith as: A denial of coverage or refusal to defend that is unreasonable, unjustified, or based on a pretextual reason—when an insurer knows or should know that its conduct violates the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing that exists in every insurance contract. In plain language: Your insurance company must handle your claim honestly, investigate fairly, and pay you if the claim is covered. If they deny a valid claim (or delay paying it unreasonably) to save money, that’s bad faith. The “Implied Covenant of […]