Resources

Imagine this: you lend your car to a friend for a quick errand, but an hour later, you get a call that they’ve been involved in a car accident while driving your car. Your mind races—who is responsible? Will your insurance cover the accident? Could you, as the car owner, be held liable for any damages? Understanding your liability when someone else is driving your car and gets in an accident is crucial to protecting yourself legally and financially.

This blog post will break down everything you need to know about liability when someone else drives your car and causes an accident. We will explore how car insurance policies work in these situations, when you may be held liable, and what steps you should take if this happens.

Understanding Car Insurance Coverage When Someone Else Drives Your Car

When you let someone else drive your car, your car insurance policy generally follows the vehicle rather than the driver. This means that in most cases, your insurance coverage will cover damages from an accident while driving your car, even if someone else is behind the wheel.

However, insurance coverage depends on several factors:

• Permission: If you gave explicit permission to the driver, most insurance companies would cover the accident under your policy.
• Exclusions: Some auto insurance policies exclude coverage for certain drivers, such as those with a poor driving record or those who were driving under the influence.
• Primary vs. Secondary Insurance: Your liability insurance may be the primary coverage, but the driver’s insurance could act as secondary coverage if the damages exceed your policy limits.

When Does Your Car Insurance Not Cover an Accident?

Your car insurance company may refuse to cover damages in specific situations, such as:

• The driver borrowed your car without your permission
• The person driving your car was excluded from your policy
• Your car was stolen and involved in an accident

In these cases, the person driving your car or their insurance policies may be responsible for covering the damages.

Who Is Liable for Damages When Someone Else Causes an Accident?

If someone else drives your car and gets into an accident, liability generally depends on the circumstances of the accident and the insurance policies involved.

Scenarios Where You May Be Held Liable

There are specific situations where you, as the car owner, may be held responsible:

1. Negligent Entrustment: If you knowingly loan your car to someone who is unfit to drive (e.g., they are intoxicated, unlicensed, or have a reckless driving history), you could be held liable for any damages.
2. Permissive Use: If you allow someone to drive your car and they cause an accident, your insurance would generally cover it, but you could still be financially responsible if the damages exceed your policy limits.
3. Employer Responsibility: If an employee drives your vehicle for work-related tasks and causes a crash, the employer (or you, if you own the business) may be liable for the damages.

When the Driver Is Responsible

There are instances where the person driving your vehicle is responsible for the accident:

• If the driver was driving under the influence, they would likely bear full responsibility.
• If they borrowed your car without permission, their insurance policies might be the only coverage available.
• If they were at fault for the accident, their insurance could be responsible for covering damages.

Steps to Take If Someone Else Crashes Your Car

If you find yourself in the unfortunate situation where someone else drives your car and causes an accident, follow these steps:

1. Confirm Safety and Gather Information

• Ensure everyone involved in the accident is safe.
• Gather details, including the driver’s insurance, license, and contact information.
• Take photos of the accident scene, vehicle damage, and road conditions.

2. Contact Your Car Insurance Company

• Notify your car insurance company immediately about the accident.
• Provide all necessary details, including whether the driver had permission to use your car.
• Confirm what part of the accident is covered under your insurance policies.

3. Determine Liability and Seek Legal Assistance

• If the accident is complex or involves severe damages, consult a car accident lawyer.
• If the person driving your car caused severe damage, you may need a car accident attorney to protect your interests.
• If there is a dispute about who should cover the accident, a lawyer can clarify legal responsibilities.

Conclusion

When you allow someone else to drive your car, you may also take on financial and legal risks if they cause an accident. Your car insurance coverage often extends to the driver, but in some cases, you could be held liable for any damages. Understanding your car insurance policy and being mindful of who you let borrow your car can help you avoid costly consequences.

If you or someone you know is dealing with a car accident while driving someone else’s car, seeking legal assistance from an experienced car accident lawyer can help navigate the complexities of insurance policies and liability insurance.

FAQs

What happens if someone else drives my car and has an accident?

If they had permission, your car insurance coverage typically applies first. However, the person driving your vehicle may also need to use their own insurance if damages exceed your policy limits.

Can I be held liable if my friend crashes my car?

Yes, in cases of negligent entrustment or if your liability insurance is insufficient to cover the accident.

Does my car insurance cover a stolen car involved in an accident?

If your car was stolen, you are generally not held liable for any damages, and comprehensive insurance may cover the damage.

What if someone drives my car without permission and causes an accident?

If someone borrows your car without permission, their insurance policies may be responsible for covering damages. However, you may need legal help to prove they lacked permission.

Should I contact a car accident lawyer if someone else crashes my car?

Yes, especially if you are being held liable or if the insurance companies are disputing coverage. A car accident lawyer can help clarify your legal options.